Id: arxiv/2611.21081 Url: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21081 Tags: math.ST Score: 0 Title: The random analyst Domain: math.ST Source: arxiv Authors: G{é}rard Biau Reviews: 0 Subject: math.ST Category: research Comments: 0 Disputed: false Division: math Mentions: 0 Discussed: 0 Published: 2026-11-16 Page: https://delphi.science/r/arxiv/2611.21081 Modern data-analysis pipelines increasingly involve searching among candidate analyses before reporting an estimate. We investigate the replicability of the resulting conclusions by studying independent repetitions of the entire search-and-report procedure on new samples. Can the reported estimates become increasingly similar across studies while remaining systematically displaced from the scientific target? We first show that this can happen in a simple Gaussian model. Although every prespecified candidate estimator is unbiased and consistent, searching over exponentially many candidates…